CSPI Urges Dismissal of "Pink Slime" Defamation Suit Against ABC and Whistle Blowers

Statement of CSPI Executive Director Michael F. Jacobson

December 18, 2013

The right of reporters, bloggers, and other members of news media to speak to government or industry whistle blowers and to broadcast or publish their findings is at the heart of the First Amendment. The lawsuit waged by Beef Products, Inc., against ABC News and people the network interviewed is a blatant, even thuggish, attempt to chill the free speech of journalists, government scientists, and anyone else who wants to speak out through the news media. We hope Judge Gering dismisses it altogether.

It's obvious why BPI prefers the term "lean finely textured beef" to "pink slime." "Pink slime" is not a particularly appetizing term. But free speech certainly trumps a meat company's public relations problem. CSPI certainly reserves its right to use the term "pink slime" even though we acknowledge that lean finely textured beef is safe. But in the unlikely event the company were to prevail in its lawsuit, news reporting on virtually everything that Americans come into contact with, from food to drugs to cars to cribs, would change overnight. And people would have no clue what stories weren't being reported for fear of a lawsuit from a thin-skinned corporate bully like BPI.


Get Updates Via Email

Journalists can receive CSPI news releases via email.
Not a journalist?

Sign Up for Email Now



Subscribe Now

Subscribe Now »

Subscribe Today and Save!

In Recent Issues

Cover Story: 1 in 8: What You May Not Know About Breast Cancer

Special Feature: Soy Oh Soy: Is It Really Bad For You?

Brand-Name Rating: Pasta Sauce

Subscribe Now

Request permission to reuse content

The use of information from this site for commercial purposes is strictly prohibited without written permission from CSPI.